Marc Fearby’s Home Page » Blog Archive » My kingdom for a perfect operating system
I cannot argue with his post in most respects – esp Windows XP, Vista, etc. And sure Mac OS X isn’t perfect. Also – what I assume he means by finder’s lack of a address bar is the “path” in mac speak – if you “right click” or ctrl-click on the top you can customize finder windows to show things like delete and “path” buttons – there you can see where you are. It does require a mouse move and click though.
I have to give it to him on the “folder” merge thing and quite frankly the “where am I” issue. My daughter once completely lost her entire documents folder when she copied the one in the root hard drive over her personal documents folder. It asked her but she didn’t realize what she was doing. It broke her heart – years of homework gone. Not that she needed it and heck she was only 10 but she loves her homework (God bless her). XP’s approach is a little more safe, and Apple is arrogant about stupidity – which can be frustrating.
So, I have to agree with a few of his points but even the well thought out reasons outlined in “Top 10 Reasons Apple Dock…” referenced don’t mention why it is a great tool as well. Its easy to look for bad…as I tell my kids, look for good and you are always going to find happiness. Then again, you may also never improve the world. I won’t be at the WWDC so I won’t see Leopard until this fall. The fact is, Windows tried to do everything in that start menu. They even put it on the Windows CE (whatever the hand held OS is) screen. Dinky little screen with a menu shooting up and over to find what you want – when Palm put the most important things right there in front of you. That to me is what the Doc is all about. They add a little to other areas where it makes sense too. Widgets, Expose, and the new Spaces is unique, Spotlight continues to get better, perhaps they will add these features into Finder; or find an alternative. Will that be good enough? If you try to do too much in the doc you will re-create all these other tools and it will become a fat pig. And improving Finder with an address bar to let you know where you are might help – its the way spotlight works now – when you hover over a found item it give it to you.
I’ll point you Mac users to this fantastic page – Dan Rodney’s Mac OS X quick reference guide. It helps you navigate and work OS X.
